As a sophomore, he became a starter at punter, registering 32 punts for 1,169 yards (36.5 yard average) and a long of 50 yards. As a junior, he was ranked 17th in the country with a punting average of 40.6 yards, while making 63 punts for 2,556 yards with a long of 68 yards.
As a senior, he posted 53 punts for 1,921 yards (36.2-yard average) and a long of 54 yards.
On May 2, 1973, he was claimed off waivers by the St. Louis Cardinals.[3] He was released on August 9.[4] After his release, he returned to play semi-professional football with the Hagerstown Bears of the Seaboard Football League.[5]
On October 30, 1974, he was signed as a free agent by the Dallas Cowboys, to replace punter Marv Bateman.[7] On September 14, 1975, he was released after averaging 39.8 yards per punt during the preseason and being passed on the depth chart by rookie Mitch Hoopes.
On September 3, 1976, he was signed by the New York Jets.[10] He was tied for ninth punter in the league with a 39.7 yards average and had a punt of 72 yards (third longest in franchise history) against the San Francisco 49ers. He was released on September 28, 1977.[11]
Carrell earned a bachelor's degree while at Florida State University and also helped to found a chapter of the Beta Theta Pi fraternity while he was a student athlete.
References
^"In Brief". June 9, 1972. Retrieved February 19, 2020.