Over his first two years with Michigan State, Naymick appeared in 51 games as a reserve. He started the first seven games of the 2005–06 season before sitting out the rest of the season due to a shoulder injury, earning a medical redshirt. He returned to the line-up in 2006–07 and appeared in 35 games, starting the final 11 contests of the season. As a senior in 2007–08, he appeared in 36 games, starting 23, including the final 22 contests of the season. He finished his college career as Michigan State's career leader in blocked shots with 134.[1]
Professional career
On July 20, 2008, Naymick signed a one-year contract with Polish team Kotwica Kołobrzeg. He parted ways with the team on March 31, 2009,[2] not before helping Kołobrzeg win the Polish Cup title.
On August 19, 2011, Naymick signed a one-year contract with Czech team ČEZ Nymburk.[5] He re-signed with Nymburk for another season on July 31, 2012.[2]
In September 2017, Naymick signed Link Tochigi Brex, returning to the team for a second stint.[9] He left Tochigi Brex in December 2017, and joined Otsuka Corporation Alphas in January 2018.