Commesso joined the Rockford IceHogs, Chicago's American Hockey League (AHL) affiliate, in 2023. He made his first career AHL start on October 13 in a 7–2 victory over the San Jose Barracuda. Commesso led the IceHogs in almost every goaltending statistic during his first year in the AHL. He finished the season with an 18–16–3–1 record, along with a 2.65 goals-against average and a .906 save percentage.[4]
On December 12, 2024, Commesso made his NHL debut, entering in relief of starter Arvid Söderblom midway through the third period after Söderblom allowed a fifth goal to the host New York Islanders. Commesso faced two shots and did not allow a goal.[5]. On December 14, Commesso made his first NHL start against the New Jersey Devils. He made 20 saves in a 4-1 loss.[6].
International play
Commesso competed in the 2022 Winter Olympics, where he became the youngest starting goaltender in United States history.[7] In his debut against China, he earned a shutout while recording 29 saves.[8]