Disability and LGBTQ identities

Disability
Theory and models
Education
Therapy
Societal implications
Personal assistance
Socioeconomic assistance
  • Groups
  • Organizations
Parasports
Culture
Part of a series on
LGBTQ topics
      
Sexual orientation and gender
History
General
Identities
Culture
Rights
Health
Social attitudes
Issues
Academic fields and discourse
LGBTQ portal

Disability and LGBTQ+ identity can both play significant roles in the life of an individual. Disability and sexuality can often intersect, for many people being both disabled and LGBTQ+ can result in double marginalization.[1][2] The two identities, either by themselves or in tandem, can complicate questions of discrimination (in workplaces, schools, or otherwise) and can effect access to resources such as accommodations, support groups, and elder care.

LGBTQ+ identity and its relationship to disability has also been analyzed by academics. LGBTQ+ identities have been pathologized as mental disorders by some groups, both historically and in the present.[3][4][5] Alternatively, some activists, scholars, and researchers have suggested that under the social model of disability, society's failures to accommodate and include LGBTQ+ people makes such an identity function as a disability.[6]

Rates of disability

In general, studies have found that LGBTQ+ populations report higher rates of disability than the general population.

In studies looking at populations in the United States, LGBTQ populations report higher rates of disability compared to the heterosexual and cisgender majorities.[1][7][8] According to the Movement Advance Project in 2019, an estimated 3 to 5 million lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people in the United States have a disability.[9] A 2022 report about the United States by the Human Rights Campaign reported that 36% of LGBTQ+ adults have self reported having a disability while 24% of non-LGBTQ adults self reported having a disability.[10] A 2024 report on American LGBTQ youth found that 29.7% of the 3,100 youth polled were diagnosed with a disability, with these numbers being higher for trans youth (33.3%) than cisgender LGBQ+ youth (20.6%).[11]

In a 2020 study of Australian LGBTQ people, 38% of respondents reported having at least one disability.[12]

In a 2022 study of Canadians with disabilities, 8.7% of the disabled population also identified as 2S (two-spirit) or LGBTQ+ . The same study found that "the 2SLGBTQ+ population with disabilities is younger than the non-2SLGBTQ+ population with disabilities". Of the 2SLGBTQ+ population with disabilities, the majority (69.9%) reported a disability related to mental health.[13]

In China, a rough estimate of cantong, or LGBTQ people with disabilities, is about 5 million people.[14]

Academic theory

Academics writing about queer theory and disability studies have drawn from one another's work, as both examine what society deems as normal and how those people outside of that definition are treated.[15] For example, theorist Robert McRuer has used Adrienne Rich's idea of compulsory heterosexuality to examine how society might also perpetuate "compulsory able-bodiness".[16] In Feminist, Queer, Crip Alison Kafer's "engagement with the intersections of gender and cripping time is never stronger than in the instances where she makes explicit the mainstream responses to gendered disability narratives".[17]

History

Until 1990, the World Health Organization classified homosexuality as a mental disorder.[3] In 2019, the organization also removed "gender identity disorder", referring to transgender people, from the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems.[18]

United States

Street Transvestite Action Revolutionaries (STAR), a group founded by Marsha P. Johnson and Sylvia Rivera, worked both to support trans and gay people and disabled people.[19] STAR called for the end of non-consensual psychiatric incarcerations of LGBTQ+ individuals, something Johnson had experienced in her life.[19]

Other activists in the United States involved in both the gay rights and the disability rights movements include Kenny Fries,[20] Barbara Jordan, and Connie Panzarino.[21]

In the late 1970s, disabled attendees and groups were recorded at San Francisco Pride.[22]

In the 1980s and early 1990s, the case of Sharon Kowalski was taken up by both disability and gay rights activists.[21] Kowalski, a lesbian, had become disabled after a car accident, and her father had been awarded custody of her. Her father then moved Kowalski to a nursing home five hours away from her partner, Karen Thompson, and prevented Thompson from visiting Kowalski. In a victory for both groups of activists, the Minnesota Court of Appeals ruled that Thompson be made Kowalski's legal guardian, in line with Kowalski's wishes.

Disability Pride Month was founded in 1990, inspired by both gay and Black pride.[21]

In June 2014, the White House hosted a panel on LGBT issues and disability.[23]

Medical care

Until 1973, homosexuality was included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.[3][4][24] Although many gay liberation activists celebrated its removal, others were blase or wary about aligning the wider community with psychiatric associations or providers.[25] Before its removal, both anti-psychiatric and gay liberation activists had used homosexuality's inclusion in the DSM as leverage to criticize psychiatry as a whole.[25]

In the late 1970s, Bobbie Lea Bennett became the first trans woman to have her gender-affirming surgery covered by Medicare. Bennett, as a wheelchair user with osteogenesis imperfecta, was already covered by the policy, which forced the courts to decide whether the surgery was considered a "legitimate medical treatment"; up until this point, transgender activists trying to have their surgeries covered under the policy had to argue that being transgender, in and of itself, was a disability.[26]

The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) made disability a protected class in the United States. However, the law purposefully excluded homosexuality, bisexuality, and "[t]ransvestitism, transsexualism...[and] gender identity disorders not resulting from physical impairments" from the act's definition of disability.[6] This exclusion has led to some cases in which prosecutors have argued that gender dysphoria is a "gender identity disorder" that therefore cannot be accommodated under the ADA.[6] In 1998, Bragdon v. Abbott confirmed that HIV was considered a protected disability under the ADA, which has been used to protect HIV-positive individuals in years since, many of whom are members of the LGBT community.[6]

In 2017, Kate Lynn Blatt became the first trans woman who was allowed to sue her employer under the ADA for not accommodating her gender dysphoria.[27]

Challenges

LGBTQ+ individuals with disabilities are subject to higher rates of childhood bullying[28] and lack of comprehensive sex education.[28]

LGBTQ+ individuals with disabilities who are assisted by family or caregivers may have more difficulty finding time to be intimate with or have sex with their partners.[29] Those who live in group homes might similarly have difficulties with maintaining privacy within relationships.[29] People who cannot drive or require assistance while traveling may have more limited opportunities to attend LGBTQ+ support groups, community spaces, or events.[29]

Limited travel opportunities may lead some disabled LGBTQ+ people, especially those living in socially conservative areas, to pursue online or long-distance relationships.[14]

Discrimination

Medical care

In some cases, medical providers or other authorities will use a transgender person's disability status to deny them gender-affirming care, using the argument that the person is not capable enough to give informed consent for such care.[6] Similarly, people may deny LGBTQ+ self-identification on the basis of someone's disability, particularly intellectual disability.[30]

Alternatively, LGBTQ+ individuals may avoid seeking needed medical care, such as STI testing,[31] or accessing disability services because of prejudiced comments or treatment by their healthcare providers.[6][32][33] Those who do seek medical care, but do not disclose their identity, may have adverse health consequences when their identity is not taken into account by their physicians.[33]

LGBTQ+ individuals with disabilities that need in-home care may be especially vulnerable, as they may be less likely to have family that can care for them, and nurses or other hired caregivers may make prejudiced or uneducated statements to their patients.[30][29][34][35][36][37] Some individuals may choose to change their appearance or behavior so as to appear straight or cisgender to caregivers.[34] For people who are unsure of their sexual or gender identity, caregivers or assistants may be unwilling to discuss the topic with their client.[29]

Interpersonal relationships

Both LGBTQ+ people and people with disabilities face high rates of sexual assault compared to the general population; for people who are both LGBTQ+ and disabled, the statistics are even higher.[8]

Employment

Limited opportunities for employment may drive some disabled LGBTQ+ people to remained closeted at work, to avoid being fired.[14] For disabled individuals who are out, their disability and LGBTQ+ identity may further limit job opportunities.[38]

A 2020 study of American lawyers found that nearly 60% of respondents who were both LGBTQ+ and disabled reported having experienced discrimination in the workplace related to their identities.[39]

Intercommunity issues

A common complaint among disabled LGBTQ+ people is that the LGBTQ+ community does not discuss disability, and the disabled community does not discuss queer identities. This is particularly an issue among the LGBTQ+ movements in countries such as China[14] and Nepal.[38]

Within the LGBTQ+ community, accessibility remains an important issue.[9][40] Not all LGBTQ+ community spaces, for example, have accessible buildings or parking, sign language interpretation, Braille signage, or TTY services.[9][41] LGBTQ+ events, such as Pride events and marches, may have routes which are difficult to navigate for those in wheelchairs or using mobility devices, or spaces that are too overwhelming for those with sensory sensitivities.[42][43] Lectures, gatherings, or film screenings may lack sign language interpretation or closed captions.[42] This may be further complicated by limited budgets that organizations or groups have, leaving little funding to better cater to disabled people.[44]

Ableism more widely is also an issue within the LGBTQ+ community.[29][45][46] LGBTQ+ people with disabilities have also expressed that a focus in the community on appearance can lead to disabled people feeling excluded or undesirable as partners.[40][47][48][49][50][51] Attitudes that disabled people are inherently asexual are also still prevalent.[48]

Within disabled communities, homophobia and transphobia remain as important issues.[40]

Multiple organizations have been founded that specifically aim to serve those in the LGBTQ+ community with disabilities. International organizations include Blind LGBT Pride International.[52]

In the U.S., these include Services & Advocacy for GLBT Elders (SAGE). In the U.K., these include Brownton Abbey,[53] Deaf Rainbow UK,[53] ParaPride,[48] and Regard.[53] In Australia there is Inclusive Rainbow Voices (IRV)[54] and Rainbow Rights & Advocacy.[10]

In media

Disabled LGBTQ+ characters in movies and television tend to be rare; a 2021 report by GLAAD found zero such characters in any major American movie releases that year.[55] Their 2022 report found only 27 characters - 4.5% of all counted LGBTQ+ characters - who were also disabled.[56] However, some movies and television shows featured disabled and LGBTQ+ characters do exist, such as Margarita with a Straw (2014), about a bisexual student with cerebral palsy,[57] Queer as Folk (2022), which features a wheelchair-using side character, and Special (2019), a series about a gay man with cerebral palsy.[58] Such characters have also been included in some children's shows, including The Dragon Prince (2018), which has a recurring Deaf lesbian character, and Dead End: Paranormal Park (2022), which has an autistic bisexual protagonist.

Some LGBTQ+ magazines have specifically addressed a disabled audience, such as the magazine Dykes, Disability & Stuff, from Madison, Wisconsin, which was founded in the late 1980s and was published until 2001.[59] More general LGBTQ+ magazines have also addressed disability; lesbian magazine Sinister Wisdom, for example, made "On Disability" the theme of their Winter 1989/1990 issue.[60]

See also

Further reading

  • Surfus, Chris R. (April 19, 2023). "A Statistical Understanding of Disability in the LGBT Community". Statistics and Public Policy. 10 (1). doi:10.1080/2330443X.2023.2188056. S2CID 257458044.

References

  1. ^ a b "Understanding Disability in the LGBTQ+ Community". Human Rights Campaign. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  2. ^ Santinele Martino, Alan (May 2017). "Cripping sexualities: An analytic review of theoretical and empirical writing on the intersection of disabilities and sexualities". Sociology Compass. 11 (5): e12471. doi:10.1111/soc4.12471.
  3. ^ a b c Drescher, Jack (2015-12-04). "Out of DSM: Depathologizing Homosexuality". Behavioral Sciences. 5 (4): 565–575. doi:10.3390/bs5040565. ISSN 2076-328X. PMC 4695779. PMID 26690228.
  4. ^ a b Kunzel, Regina (2018-07-10), Rembis, Michael; Kudlick, Catherine; Nielsen, Kim E. (eds.), "The Rise of Gay Rights and the Disavowal of Disability in the United States", The Oxford Handbook of Disability History (1 ed.), Oxford University Press, pp. 459–476, doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190234959.013.27, ISBN 978-0-19-023495-9, retrieved 2023-08-11
  5. ^ "Professionally speaking: challenges to achieving equality for LGBT people". European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. 2016-03-01. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  6. ^ a b c d e f Rodríguez-Roldán, Victoria (2020-01-01). "The Intersection Between Disability and LGBT Discrimination and Marginalization". American University Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law. 28 (3).
  7. ^ Fredriksen-Goldsen, Karen I.; Kim, Hyun-Jun; Barkan, Susan E. (January 2012). "Disability Among Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Adults: Disparities in Prevalence and Risk". American Journal of Public Health. 102 (1): e16–e21. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2011.300379. ISSN 0090-0036. PMC 3490559. PMID 22095356.
  8. ^ a b "LGBTQ+ People with Disabilities". GLAAD. 2022-02-21. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  9. ^ a b c "LGBT PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES" (PDF). Movement Advancement Project.
  10. ^ a b "Understanding Disability in the LGBTQ+ Community". The Human Rights Campaign. 2022-08-12. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  11. ^ "2024 Disabled LGBTQ+ Youth Report". Human Rights Campaign. Retrieved 2024-11-19.
  12. ^ Hill, A. O.; Bourne, A.; McNair, R.; Carman, M.; Lyons, A. (2020). Private Lives 3: The health and wellbeing of LGBTIQ people in Australia (PDF). ARCSHS Monograph Series No. 122. Melbourne, Australia: Australian Research Centre in Sex, Health and Society, La Trobe University. ISBN 978-0-6488887-4-1.
  13. ^ "A profile of 2SLGBTQ+ persons with disabilities, 2022". Statistics Canada. Government of Canada. 2024-07-08. Retrieved 2024-11-19.
  14. ^ a b c d Yiying, Fan (Feb 22, 2018). "China's Gay and Disabled Face Double Discrimination". Sixth Tone. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  15. ^ Sherry, Mark (December 2004). "Overlaps and contradictions between queer theory and disability studies". Disability & Society. 19 (7): 769–783. doi:10.1080/0968759042000284231. ISSN 0968-7599. S2CID 218525189.
  16. ^ McRuer, Robert (2016-10-19). "Compulsory Able-Bodiedness and Queer/Disabled Existence". In Davis, Lennard J. (ed.). The Disability Studies Reader. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 978-1-317-39786-1.
  17. ^ Kannen, Victoria (4 March 2015). "Feminist, queer, crip". Journal of Gender Studies. 24 (2): 247–248. doi:10.1080/09589236.2015.1005970. S2CID 143030310.
  18. ^ "WHO Drops Being Transgender from List of 'Mental Disorders'". Time. 2019-05-28. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  19. ^ a b Brownworth, Victoria A. (2020-10-20). "The Intersection Of LGBTQ+ History And Disability". Philadelphia Gay News. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  20. ^ Wolfe, Kathi (2022-09-28). "Author Kenny Fries on being queer, disabled, and Jewish". Washington Blade. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  21. ^ a b c "Pride and Protest – LGBT+ Disability Activism, 1985-1995". review.gale.com. 2021-12-03. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  22. ^ "1977 and 1978 Gay Freedom Day Parade video". GLBT Historical Society. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  23. ^ "Disability Justice Is LGBT Justice: A Conversation with Movement Leaders". Center for American Progress. 2015-07-30. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  24. ^ Winterhalter, Elizabeth (2021-05-26). "How LGBTQ+ Activists Got "Homosexuality" out of the DSM". JSTOR Daily. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  25. ^ a b Lewis, Abram J. (2016). ""We Are Certain of Our Own Insanity": Antipsychiatry and the Gay Liberation Movement, 1968–1980". Journal of the History of Sexuality. 25 (1): 83–113. doi:10.7560/JHS25104. ISSN 1043-4070. JSTOR 24616618. S2CID 146703192.
  26. ^ Matte, Nicholas (November 2014). "Sex, Disability, and Economic Discrimination". Historicizing Liberal American Transnormativities: Media, Medicine, Activism, 1960-1990 (Ph.D.). University of Toronto. pp. 244–249. hdl:1807/68460. Retrieved 28 July 2020.
  27. ^ "U.S. judge allows first transgender person to sue under disability law". Reuters. 2017-05-19. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  28. ^ a b "Analysis: We must better address the needs of LGBT people with disabilities". NBC News. 2017-09-15. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  29. ^ a b c d e f Smith, Jennifer (2017-06-22). "LGBTQ+ People With Developmental Disabilities Need Respect, Privacy, and Access to Community". Slate. ISSN 1091-2339. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  30. ^ a b O'Shea, Amie; Piantedosi, Diana (2022-06-13). "'What matters is hope, freedom and saying who you are.' What LGBTQ+ people with intellectual disabilities want everyone to know". The Conversation. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  31. ^ Gurza, Andrew (2016-05-20). "I'm a Queer Man with Disabilities & STD Testing Isn't Accessible—Something Needs to Change". www.out.com. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  32. ^ Smith, Elizabeth; Zirnsak, Tessa-May; Power, Jennifer; Lyons, Anthony; Bigby, Christine (January 2022). "Social inclusion of LGBTQ+ and gender diverse adults with intellectual disability in disability services: A systematic review of the literature". Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities. 35 (1): 46–59. doi:10.1111/jar.12925. ISSN 1360-2322. PMID 34309149. S2CID 236431413.
  33. ^ a b Foglia, Mary Beth; Fredriksen-Goldsen, Karen I. (2014). "Health Disparities among LGBT Older Adults and the Role of Nonconscious Bias". The Hastings Center Report. 44 (5): S40–S44. doi:10.1002/hast.369. ISSN 0093-0334. JSTOR 44159365. PMC 4365932. PMID 25231786.
  34. ^ a b Carter, Christin (2023-01-27). "The caregiver crisis hits LGBTQ+ elderly and disabled people hardest". Wisconsin Examiner. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  35. ^ "MPs hear of barriers facing LGBT disabled people who need social care". Disability News Service. 2019-06-20. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  36. ^ Reygan, Finn; Henderson, Neil; Khan, Jamil (January 2022). "'I'm black, a woman, disabled and lesbian': LGBT ageing and care services at the intersections in South Africa". Sexualities. 25 (1–2): 63–78. doi:10.1177/1363460720975322. ISSN 1363-4607. S2CID 229417941.
  37. ^ Timoner, Rachel (1992-10-15). "Double Minority: On Being Disabled and Gay". Bay Area Reporter. Vol. XXII, no. 42. p. 25.
  38. ^ a b "For queer people with disabilities, the path to acceptance is more arduous". kathmandupost.com. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  39. ^ "LGBTQ+ lawyers and attorneys with disabilities report prevalent discrimination, ABA study says". ABA Journal. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  40. ^ a b c Martino, Alan Santinele; Coombs, Emily (2023-06-25). "Making pride more inclusive means creating space for 2SLGBTQ+ people with disabilities". The Conversation. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  41. ^ Dubreuil, Laurence Brisson (May 13, 2023). "Calgary queer venues lack accessibility. A new campaign could help change that". CBC News. Retrieved July 21, 2023.
  42. ^ a b Kim, Sarah. "Pride Month Too Often Overlooks LGBTQ+ Members With Disabilities". Forbes. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  43. ^ Kliem, Theresa (June 15, 2023). "Accessibility issues at Pride events, LGBTQ+ spaces can be isolating, say people with disabilities". CBC News.
  44. ^ Richards, Mary (25 June 1987). "A Silence Not Golden". Bay Area Reporter. Vol. 17, no. 26. p. 25.
  45. ^ Lewis, Laura Foran; Ward, Caroline; Jarvis, Noah; Cawley, Eleni (2021-07-01). ""Straight Sex is Complicated Enough!": The Lived Experiences of Autistics Who are Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Asexual, or Other Sexual Orientations". Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. 51 (7): 2324–2337. doi:10.1007/s10803-020-04696-w. ISSN 1573-3432. PMID 32968942. S2CID 221884388.
  46. ^ Kelleher, Patrick (2023-01-30). "Gay deaf man shared 'hurtful' Grindr messages to make point about queer ableism". PinkNews. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  47. ^ Millard, Elizabeth (2022-02-14). "Life at the Intersection of Disability and LGBTQ+". Quest | Muscular Dystrophy Association. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  48. ^ a b c Mayor, Lola (2022-06-18). "Pride month: 'Being disabled and gay - I've faced barriers'". BBC News. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  49. ^ Jackson, Callum (2023-03-06). "LGBTQ+ body standards are even more menacing for disabled queer people". LGBTQ+ Nation. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  50. ^ "'Not hiding is an act of revolution': Dating as an LGBTQIA+ person with a disability". ABC Everyday. 2022-08-23. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  51. ^ Jones, Peter (26 January 2017). "Wheels of Change: Dating for Gay Men with Disabilities". Medill School of Journalism. Northwestern University. Archived from the original on 21 April 2021. Retrieved 14 March 2021.
  52. ^ Wolfe, Kathi (2022-06-09). "Disabled queer people increasingly feel Pride in themselves". Washington Blade. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  53. ^ a b c "5 LGBT disability organisations you should support". Stonewall. 2020-11-17. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  54. ^ Dobson, Tileah (2023-04-22). "New Organisation That Advocates For LGBT+ People With Disabilities Launched In Melbourne". Star Observer. Retrieved 2023-07-21.
  55. ^ "These Queer, Disabled Characters Are Bringing Unfiltered Representation to Your Screens". Them. 2022-07-26. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  56. ^ "Where We Are on TV Report 2022-2023 - GLAAD". glaad.org. 2023-03-16. Retrieved 2023-08-14.
  57. ^ Carrie (2016-09-27). "Margarita With a Straw Comes to Netflix, (Almost) Delivers the Disabled Queer Character We Need". Autostraddle. Retrieved 2023-07-22.
  58. ^ "Netflix's 'Special' hopes to break new ground for disability representation on TV". USA TODAY. Retrieved 2023-08-14.
  59. ^ "Dykes, Disability and Stuff (Madison, WI) Winter, 1988-1989 Vol. 1 Issue. 3". Dykes, Disability and Stuff. 1988–1989. pp. [1]–. Retrieved 2023-08-11.
  60. ^ Ruth, Barbara; Edgington, Amy; zana; Hawthorne, Susan; Hugs, Diane; Rome, Jo Anne; Dinnerstein, Barbara N.; Myers, Teresa; Sorella, Naja; Pratt, Pamela; Winnow, Jackie; Dee, Mandy; Lauby, Adrienne; Lambert, Sandra; Smith, Tee (1990-01-01). "On Disability". Sinister Wisdom (39).