Since the 1960s there has been a tradition of annually selecting the best footballer in each position, to create a special team of the year. Between 1963 and 1967 these players received what was known as Cú Chulainn awards. In 1971 these awards were formalised into the annual All Star Awards. Including Sean O'Connell's Cú Chulainn award in 1967, Derry have received 28 All Stars.
K Stevenson; S McCullagh, M Conway (captain), E McKeever; C Brunton (0–1), L Hinphey, P Sweeney; R Kennedy, P O'Kane; R Convery (2–7 (1–0 ‘65’, 0-5f)), Gregory Biggs, D McGrellis (0–2); S McBride (3–3 (0–1 sl)), K Hinphey (0–1), J O'Dwyer. Subs used: R McCloskey, P Hearty (0–1), A Rafferty, C Quinn, Gary Biggs.
Daryl McDermott, Stephen Henry, Ruairi McCloskey (captain), Sean McNicholl, Michael Kirkpatrick (0-03), Mark Craig, Cormac McKenna, Ben Dodds (0-01), Niall Holly, Gareth O'Kane (0-04), Oisin McCloskey (0-02), Paddy Henry (0-03), Sam Dodds (0-01), Kevin O'Neill (0-01), Seán Leo McGoldrick (2-01).
A. McPeake (Lavey), T. Clarke (Greenlough), Theresa Halferty (Lisnamuck), Carrie Rankin (Greenlough), M. Dorrity (Lavey), M. McSwiggan (Lisnamuck), Patsy McCloskey (Greenlough), K. McCloskey (Greenlough), K. Madden (Greenlough), Pat O'Brien (Lisnamuck), A. Bryson (Lisnamuck), R. McAllister (Greenlough) Subs – A. Cassidy (Greenlough), P. McPeake (Lavey), K. Connor (? club)
The above list of honours may be incomplete. Please add any other honours you know of.
B. ^ The team listed for winning the 1954 Ulster Championship is actually the team that played Dublin in the 1954 All-Ireland final, it is likely the same or very similar to the team that beat Antrim in that year's Ulster final.