McGuire was awarded the Harry Sunderland Trophy in two Grand Finals, one of only three men to do so, alongside his former team-mates Kevin Sinfield and Rob Burrow. McGuire was also the first player to score 200 tries in the Super League and he became the highest try-scorer in the competition's history in 2012, surpassing his former team-mate, Keith Senior.
Upon retirement, McGuire moved into the role of assistant coach at Hull Kingston Rovers. He worked under Tony Smith and later Willie Peters, as well as taking interim charge prior to Peters' arrival. Having joined the Castleford Tigers ahead of 2024, he worked as assistant coach to Craig Lingard for one season before becoming head coach from 2025.
McGuire impressed for the academy side and made his début for the Leeds Rhinos' first-grade team at Headingley Stadium, against the Salford City Reds on 6 July 2001.
By the start of the 2003's Super League VIII, McGuire had established himself as a first-team regular.
After winning three titles in a row the Leeds Rhinos struggled in 2010. McGuire excelled though, scoring 27 tries in 32 games, his equal best since his excellent 2004 season.
McGuire's season ended in controversy though, during the Leeds Rhinos' win in their first play-off match against the eventual champions the Wigan Warriors.
With just moments remaining in the match, the Leeds Rhinos led 27–26, when the Wigan Warriors broke down the left of the field, McGuire was adjudged to have pulled back the Wigan Warriors' George Carmont, preventing him from scoring a potential match-winning try.
But in doing so, McGuire suffered a serious knee injury which ruled him out for up to six-months. Meaning he'd miss the remainder of the season and the start of the next.
Former Wigan Warriors star Phil Clarke, caused further controversy by writing, "Perhaps the rugby Gods have punished him (McGuire), for his unsportsmanlike play." The comments were posted on his blog on the Sky Sports website.
In pre-season ahead of the start of the 2019's Super League XXIV, Danny announced that the 2019 campaign would be his last as a player as he revealed his intentions to retire at the end of that same year.[citation needed]
International career
Great Britain
On the back of his superb season in 2004, McGuire was named in the Great Britain squad for the Tri-Nations tournament. He made his début off the bench in Great Britain's first game defeat by Australia.
He then made his first start for Great Britain in their next match against New Zealand, playing a key role and creating the try which ensured a 22–12 victory.[citation needed]
He played from the interchange bench as England came from behind to scrape past Papua New Guinea. The final score was 32–22, in the opening game of the tournament.
England then lost 52–4, to host nation and tournament favourites, Australia.
McGuire was left out of the squad for England's final group game, where they surrendered a 24-12 half-time lead to lose 36–24 to New Zealand.
McGuire started his first game of the tournament against New Zealand in the semi-final. It also proved to be his last as despite scoring two tries, McGuire could not prevent England losing 32-22 and being eliminated.[citation needed]
Coaching career
Hull Kingston Rovers
On 20 May 2019, it was revealed that, following McGuire's retirement as a player, he would take on the role of Head of Recruitment at Hull Kingston Rovers from 2020's Super League XXV. In November 2020, Hull KR announced that he would join the coaching staff as an assistant to Tony Smith from the 2021 season.[31]
In July 2022, McGuire became interim head coach following the departure of Smith.[32] During this period, he led Hull KR to five wins from ten games.
Following the arrival of Willie Peters as head coach for 2023, McGuire resumed his previous position of assistant head coach, having recently signed a contract extension until the end of 2025.[33]
In October 2023, McGuire departed Hull KR to "enable Willie Peters to create his own coaching team".[34]
Castleford Tigers
On 17 October 2023, the Castleford Tigers announced the appointment of McGuire as assistant coach on a two-year deal, working under new head coach Craig Lingard.[35][36] The team finished the 2024 season in 10th place.[37] In October 2024, new chairman Martin Jepson completed a takeover of the club and Lingard was dismissed after one season at the helm.[38][39] With McGuire remaining in post, he quickly emerged as the leading candidate to step into the role.[40]
On 25 October 2024, Castleford confirmed that McGuire would be appointed as their new head coach on a three-year contract, marking his first permanent head coaching role.[41][42]