DPP v Majewski

DPP v Majewski
CourtJudicial Committee of the House of Lords
Full case name R v Majewski (Robert Stefan)
Decided13 April 1976
Citation[1976] UKHL 2; [1977] AC 443; [1976] 2 WLR 623; [1976] 2 All ER 142; (1976) 62 Cr App R 262; [1976] Crim LR 374; (1976) 120 SJ 299
Case history
Subsequent actionnone
Keywords
  • Voluntary intoxication
  • crime of basic intent
  • whether substitutes for mens rea

DPP v Majewski [1976] UKHL 2 is a leading English criminal law case, establishing that voluntary intoxication such as by drugs or alcohol is no defence to crimes requiring only basic intent. The mens rea requirement is satisfied by the reckless behaviour of intoxicating oneself.[1]

Facts

The defendant, Robert Stefan Majewski, committed a series of assaults while under the influence of alcohol and drugs (20 pills of Dexedrine and 8 pills of Nembutal).[2] He attacked the landlord and several customers at a public house; subsequently he attacked the police officer who drove him to the police station following his arrest, and a police inspector at the station.

He was charged with four counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm and three counts of assault on a constable in the execution of his duty.

He tried to rely on his intoxication as a "defence" to the charges.

Judgment

Dismissing his appeal, the highest criminal court held that he could not rely on intoxication, as it is no defence. It was however recognised that certain offences require a mens rea element termed specific intent. The requisite mens rea can be disproved if the defendant can prove that he was so intoxicated as to be incapable of forming such an intent.

There is no definite authority or fixed rule on what constitutes a specific intent offence. It is established that murder is[3] but manslaughter is not;[4] there are also specific intent elements in wounding with intent.[5] As a general rule, it can be said that, where recklessness will suffice as mens rea, the crime is one of basic intent.[6] An alternative model is that specific intent is when the mens rea goes beyond the actus reus, i.e. the defendant contemplates consequences beyond their physical actions.[7]

In the instant case, it was held that assault occasioning ABH is a crime of basic intent. Even when too intoxicated to form a specific intent, the Lords held that one can still form basic intent,[8] and thus the defendant's appeal was dismissed.

Even where intoxication can disprove mens rea, this is not the same as a defence (a justification or excuse for committing the offence); rather it is a denial that all the necessary elements to constitute an offence – namely actus reus and simultaneous mens rea – were present.

See also

References

  1. ^ [1977] AC 443, at 474-475
  2. ^ "News and Notes". BMJ. 1 (6020): 1286–1288. 1976. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.6020.1286. S2CID 220235802.
  3. ^ R v Beard [1920] AC 479
  4. ^ Majewski
  5. ^ Bratty v A-G for Northern Ireland [1963] AC 386
  6. ^ R v Caldwell [1983] AC 341
  7. ^ R v Morgan; Dennis J. Baker, Glanville Williams Textbook of Criminal Law,(London: 2012) at chapter 19 on Intoxication and the Criminal Law
  8. ^ [1977] AC 443, at 469

Read other articles:

Ararat International Airlines

Ararat International Airlines IATA ICAO Kode panggil 4A RRN ARARAT AVIA Didirikan2010Mulai beroperasi2010Pusat operasiBandar Udara Internasional ZvartnotsArmada2Tujuan4Kantor pusatYerevan, ArmeniaSitus webwww.araratinternationalairline.com not operational yet Ararat International Airlines adalah maskapai penerbangan yang berbasis di Yerevan, Armenia. Maskapai penerbangan ini mengoperasikan penerbangan dari Bandar Udara Internasional Zvartnots.[1] It was founded in 2010.[2] Nam...

 

Carottage

Cet article est une ébauche concernant la géologie. Vous pouvez partager vos connaissances en l’améliorant (comment ?) selon les recommandations des projets correspondants. Préparation d'un carottage dans la glace. Au premier plan, le carottier. Carottes géologiques classées dans des boîtes spécifiques (core box). Le carottage (en anglais diamond drilling, ou core drilling) est un type de forage d'exploration, visant à prélever un échantillon du sous-sol terrestre ou m...

 

Bahasa Belanda

Cari artikel bahasa  Cari berdasarkan kode ISO 639 (Uji coba)  Kolom pencarian ini hanya didukung oleh beberapa antarmuka Halaman bahasa acak Bahasa Belanda Nederlands Pengucapan[ˈneːdərlɑnts] ⓘDituturkan diBelanda, BelgiaWilayahBelanda, Flandria, Suriname; Juga di Aruba, Curaçao, dan Sint MaartenEtnis Belanda Flandria Indo Penutur25 juta jiwa (2021)[1]Jumlah (B1 dan B2): 30 juta (2021)[2][3] Rincian data penutur Jumlah penutur besert...

The Dreaming

Sacred era in Australian Aboriginal mythology For other uses, see 148780 Altjira and Dreaming (disambiguation). Dreamtime redirects here. For other uses, see Dreamtime (disambiguation). Stencil art at Carnarvon Gorge, which may be memorials, signs from or appeals to totemic ancestors or records of Dreaming stories[1] The Dreaming, also referred to as Dreamtime, is a term devised by early anthropologists to refer to a religio-cultural worldview attributed to Australian Aboriginal belie...

 

Ireng Maulana

Ireng MaulanaLahirEugene Lodewijk Willem Maulana(1944-06-15)15 Juni 1944Batavia, Hindia BelandaMeninggal6 Maret 2016(2016-03-06) (umur 71)Jakarta, IndonesiaSuami/istriMaria MaulanaAnakTomi MaulanaEsther MaulanaAndrea MaulanaNatashya MaulanaOrang tuaMax MaulanaGeorgiana SinsoeKeluargaNadine MaulanaKarier musikGenreJazz Ireng Maulana (dengan nama lahir Eugene Lodewijk Willem Maulana 15 Juni 1944 – 6 Maret 2016) adalah seorang penyanyi jazz Indonesia. Ia juga pernah bermain...

 

Classe Flyvefisken

Classe Flyvefisken[1] Le P555 Støren configuré en patrouilleur. Standard Flex 300 ou StanFlex 300Classe Tejo Caractéristiques techniques Type Navire militaire polyvalent Longueur 54 m Maître-bau 9 m Tirant d'eau 2.60 m Déplacement 320 t À pleine charge ~ 450 t Propulsion 2 diesels MTU 16V 396TB94 1 turbine à gaz General Electric LM500 Vitesse 30 nœuds (55 km/h) Caractéristiques militaires Armement 4 emplacements pour module StanFlex 2 mitrailleuses 12,7 mm Rayon d’action 2400 naut...

Шалфей обыкновенный

Шалфей обыкновенный Научная классификация Домен:ЭукариотыЦарство:РастенияКлада:Цветковые растенияКлада:ЭвдикотыКлада:СуперастеридыКлада:АстеридыКлада:ЛамиидыПорядок:ЯсноткоцветныеСемейство:ЯснотковыеРод:ШалфейВид:Шалфей обыкновенный Международное научное наз...

 

ماخارادزي كاخي

هذه المقالة يتيمة إذ تصل إليها مقالات أخرى قليلة جدًا. فضلًا، ساعد بإضافة وصلة إليها في مقالات متعلقة بها. (أكتوبر 2018) ماخارادزي كاخي معلومات شخصية الميلاد 20 أكتوبر 1987 (37 سنة)  تبليسي  الطول 1.87 م (6 قدم 1 1⁄2 بوصة) مركز اللعب وسط الجنسية جورجيا  معلومات الناد...

 

Juwana, Pati

Artikel ini bukan mengenai Jumawa. JuwanaKecamatanNegara IndonesiaProvinsiJawa TengahKabupatenPatiPemerintahan • CamatTeguh Widyatmoko, APPopulasi • Total95,597 jiwa (Juni 2.016) jiwaKode Kemendagri33.18.08 Kode BPS3318080 Luas55,93 km²Desa/kelurahan29 desa/kelurahan Perahu di Sungai Juwana di awal abad ke-20 Juwana (bahasa Jawa: ꦗꦸꦮꦤ) adalah sebuah kecamatan di Kabupaten Pati, Provinsi Jawa Tengah, Indonesia. Kecamatan Juwana merupakan kota di pesisi...

大字 (数字)

この項目には、一部のコンピュータや閲覧ソフトで表示できない文字が含まれています（詳細）。 数字の大字（だいじ）は、漢数字の一種。通常用いる単純な字形の漢数字（小字）の代わりに同じ音の別の漢字を用いるものである。 概要 壱万円日本銀行券（「壱」が大字） 弐千円日本銀行券（「弐」が大字） 漢数字には「一」「二」「三」と続く小字と、「壱」「�...

 

约翰斯顿环礁

此條目可参照英語維基百科相應條目来扩充。 (2021年5月6日)若您熟悉来源语言和主题，请协助参考外语维基百科扩充条目。请勿直接提交机械翻译，也不要翻译不可靠、低品质内容。依版权协议，译文需在编辑摘要注明来源，或于讨论页顶部标记{{Translated page}}标签。 约翰斯顿环礁Kalama Atoll 美國本土外小島嶼 Johnston Atoll 旗幟颂歌：《星條旗》The Star-Spangled Banner約翰斯頓環礁�...

 

Taksim (politique)

Pour les articles homonymes, voir Taksim. Manifestation chypriote turque, à Londres. Le Taksim (en turc : « division ») est un mouvement nationaliste et sécessionniste turc prônant l'indépendance et la reconnaissance de la République turque de Chypre du Nord dans le cadre d'une solution à deux États. C'est l'idéologie principale des partisans de l'invasion de 1974, et le concept a été attribué en 1957 par le vice-président Fazıl Küçük[1]. Graffiti « TAK...

MotoGP musim 2015

Grand Prix Sepeda Motor F.I.M. musim 2015 Sebelum: 2014 Sesudah: 2016 Moto2 musim 2015Moto3 musim 2015 Jorge Lorenzo memenangkan gelar dunia MotoGP ketiganya, dan gelar dunia kelima secara keseluruhan, dengan memenangkan balapan terakhir musim ini di Valencia. Kejuaraan Dunia FIM MotoGP 2015 adalah kelas utama dari musim Kejuaraan Dunia F.I.M. Road Racing ke-67. Kejuaraan dimenangkan oleh pembalap Spanyol Jorge Lorenzo, membalap untuk Movistar Yamaha MotoGP. Itu adalah gelar dunia ketiga dan...

 

Koda Kumi Driving Hit's 2

Koda Kumi Driving Hit's 2Album remix karya Kumi KodaDirilis31 Maret 2010Direkam1999–2010GenreHouseLabelRhythm ZoneRZCD-46204 (Jepang)Kronologi Kumi Koda Best: Third Universe/Universe(2010)Best: Third Universe/Universe2010 Koda Kumi Driving Hit's 2(2010) Eternity: Love & Songs(2010)Eternity: Love & Songs2010 Koda Kumi Driving Hit's 2 adalah album remix ketiga yang dirilis oleh penyanyi-penulis lagu Jepang Kumi Koda. Album tersebut dirilis setahun setelah Koda Kumi Driving Hit's ...

 

United States Department of Justice Tax Division

Governing body in the US department of Justice United States Department of JusticeTax DivisionSeal of the United States Department of JusticeDivision overviewFormed1934; 90 years ago (1934)JurisdictionFederal government of the United StatesHeadquartersRobert F. Kennedy Department of Justice Building950 Pennsylvania Avenue NWWashington, D.C., United StatesDivision executiveDavid A. Hubbert, Acting Assistant Attorney GeneralParent departmentU.S. Department of JusticeWebsiteOf...

Meadow

Open habitat vegetated primarily by non-woody plants For other uses, see Meadow (disambiguation) and Meadows (disambiguation). Wildflower meadow in the Bavarian Alps A meadow (/ˈmɛdoʊ/ MED-oh) is an open habitat or field, vegetated by grasses, herbs, and other non-woody plants. Trees or shrubs may sparsely populate meadows, as long as these areas maintain an open character. Meadows can occur naturally under favourable conditions, but are often artificially created from cleared shrub or woo...

 

Scotty's Junction, Nevada

Unincorporated community in the state of Nevada, United States Buildings at Scotty's Junction with the rim of Pahute Mesa to the northeast Scotty's Junction is an unincorporated community in the Sarcobatus Flat of Nye County, Nevada where State Route 267 meets with U.S. Route 95 at an elevation of 4,062 feet (1,238 m).[1][2] It was named after Walter E. Scott (a.k.a. Death Valley Scotty, of nearby Scotty's Castle fame). Nevada Public Radio maintains translator station K2...

 

غرفة تجارة وصناعة دبي

غرفة تجارة وصناعة دبيالشعارمعلومات عامةنوع المبنى مؤسسة حكومية البلد الإمارات العربية المتحدةالمدينة دبيالأبعادالارتفاع 91 متراََمعلومات أخرىموقع الويب www.dubaichamber.comتعديل - تعديل مصدري - تعديل ويكي بيانات غرفة تجارة وصناعة دُبي يشار إليه أيضًا باسم مبنى غرفة التجارة ، وهو...

Hercio

Hercio Las luces parpadean a una frecuencia de f = 0.5 Hz, 1.0 Hz y 2.0 Hz.Estándar unidades derivadas del Sistema InternacionalMagnitud frecuenciaSímbolo HzNombrada en honor de Heinrich Rudolf Hertz (1857-1894)EquivalenciasUnidades básicas del Sistema Internacional 1 Hz = s-1Unidades de Planck 1 Hz = T-1[editar datos en Wikidata] El hercio[1]​ o hertz[2]​ (símbolo Hz) es la unidad de frecuencia del Sistema Internacional de Unidades.[3]​ Definición Nombrado en...

 

Lord Advocate

Chief legal officer of the Scottish Government Not to be confused with Advocate General for Scotland. ScotlandHis Majesty's Lord AdvocateScottish Gaelic: Morair TagraidhIncumbentDorothy Bain KCsince 22 June 2021Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal ServiceTypeGreat Officer of State Law Officer of the CrownMember ofScottish Cabinet Privy Council Cabinet Sub-Committee on Legislation Scottish Government Legal DirectorateReports toFirst MinisterAppointerMonarch on the recommendation of the Firs...