As a yearling he injured an ankle bone severely enough that his racing future was put in doubt. However, he healed to where he could be trained and at age two he started in two races but showed little, most likely hampered by the effects of injury and a late start in developing his strength.
1951: three-year-old season
In his three-year-old campaign in 1951, Counterpoint was entered in the Blue Grass Stakes, an important test race for Kentucky Derby hopefuls. That year, the race was contested in two divisions because of the number of entrants. Counterpoint finished fourth in the second division of the Blue Grass but was moved up to third place after the winner, Sonic, was disqualified. His handlers then put him in the Kentucky Derby, where Counterpoint made a move at the three quarters pole but tired badly and finished eleventh to Count Turf, another son of Count Fleet.
Despite his poor showing in the Kentucky Derby, Counterpoint competed in the 1951 Preakness Stakes. Dismissed by bettors, he went off as a longshot at 25:1. He finished second, seven lengths behind Brookmeade Stable's winning colt Bold in the second-fastest time in Preakness history.
Counterpoint bruised a foot and was out of racing for two months, but in early fall he returned to the track with a win in the important Lawrence Realization Stakes. He was then entered in the Jockey Club Gold Cup, where he competed against older horses, notably Christopher Chenery's heavily favored Hill Prince, the previous year's winner and 1950 Horse of the Year. Counterpoint won the two-mile race, beating Hill Prince by a neck, then won the Empire City Gold Cup while equaling the track record and assuring himself the 1951 Horse of the Year title. He received 28 of the 31 votes for the Daily Racing Form award in November[2] and also topped the Turf and Sport Digest poll a month later.[3]
Although Counterpoint sired a number of graded stakes race winners including Hollywood Gold Cup winner Dotted Swiss, none achieved the level of racing success he had. Counterpoint died in 1969 at the Whitney farm (today part of Gainesway Farm) and was buried in its equine cemetery next to a number of other prominent horses owned by both Cornelius Vanderbilt Whitney and his father, Harry Payne Whitney.
