The district's (and Circleville's) center is the Pickaway County Courthouse. Circleville's original layout was designed to have streets radiating away from it, and it was to be enclosed by two concentric circular streets. By 1860, the "circle was squared" by subsequent development and alterations to property lines.[2]
Pickaway County Courthouse (1847, 1896). This was built in 1847 as a small Greek Revival-style courthouse. It was extensively modified in 1896 by architects Weary & Kramer, so much so that the original building was almost entirely concealed. It has smooth stone pilasters, a hipped roof, and a square tower.[2]
Circleville City Hall (1861), also known as "Circleville City Building". This was designed by local architect William Doane in "Romano-Tuscan style" (i.e. Italianate style?). As common in Italianate architecture in the United States, it has eaves ostensibly supported by decorative wooden brackets and a wooden cupola. It was in excellent condition in 1977.[2] William Doane also designed the William Marshall Anderson House, also in Circleville and National Register-listed.
Sheriff's Office & Jail (c.1890). This was at first a two-story brick-and-stone Queen Anne-style house with a round tower at its northeast corner. It was later converted to hold the sheriff's office, and a jail was added in a three-story brick extension to the rear.[2]
Masonic Lodge (1876), 113-115 W. Main St. Italianate, brick-and-stone, four-story building designed by J.T. Harris of Columbus. Its upper two floors were used for Masonic lodge purposes.[2]
The People's Bank (aka Marfield Bank) (1848), 133-135 W. Main St. This was operated as a bank by Samuel Marfield until 1877. According to the National Register nomination, this "2-story brick and stone building is the only remaining structure with a portion of its property line still part of the original circular pattern [of Circleville's original layout]."[2] The Pickaway County Historical Society restored it in 1972.[2]
The Olds Building (aka Old Masonic Lodge) (1837), 115-119 W. Main St. Three-story brick building with parapet walls. In 1977 its first floor held two businesses "which have been there since the mid-1800's."[2]
Pythian Castle, 118 N. Court St.
Circleville Post Office, 224 S. Court St. The post office was not mentioned in the 1977 National Register nomination as a contributing building, nor is it mentioned as an intrusion, but it is included within the district's boundaries.[2]
Moore House (1818, 1844, 1870), 304 S. Court St. Brick house with bracketed cornice and bracketed hoods over its doors. It was modified in 1844 by Samuel Moore (d.1902) who was "one of the most outstanding and public spirited citizens of Circleville." In 1977 the house was still owned by Moore family members.[2]
Circleville City Building, aka Circleville City Hall
