Cannibalization (marketing)

In marketing strategy, cannibalization is a reduction in sales volume, sales revenue, or market share of one product when the same company introduces a new product.

Examples

In e-commerce, some companies intentionally cannibalize their retail sales through lower prices on their online product offerings. More consumers than usual may buy the discounted products, especially if they'd previously been anchored to the retail prices. Even though their in-store sales might decline, the company may see overall gains.

Another example of cannibalization occurs when a retailer discounts a particular product. The tendency of consumers is to buy the discounted product rather than competing products with higher prices. When the promotion event is over and prices return to normal, however, the effect will tend to disappear. This temporary change in consumer behavior can be described as cannibalization, though scholars do not normally use the phrase "cannibalization" to denote such a phenomenon.

In project evaluation, the estimated profit generated from the new product must be reduced by the earnings on the lost sales.

Another common case of cannibalization is when companies, particularly retail companies, open sites too close to each other, in effect, competing for the same customers. The potential for cannibalization is often discussed[1] when considering companies with many outlets in an area, such as Starbucks or McDonald's.

Brand extension

Cannibalization is an important issue in marketing strategy when an organization aims to carry out brand extension. Normally, when a brand extension is carried out from one sub-category (e.g. Marlboro) to another sub-category (e.g. Marlboro Light), there is an eventuality of a part of the former's sales being taken away by the latter. However, if the strategic intent of such an extension is to capture a larger market of a different market segment notwithstanding the potential loss of sales in an existing segment, the move to launch the new product can be termed as "cannibalization strategy". In India, where the passenger-car segment is going up dramatically since the turn of this century, Maruti Suzuki's launch of Suzuki Alto in the same sub-category as Maruti 800, which was the leader of the small-car segment to counter the competition from Hyundai is seen to be a classic case of cannibalization strategy.

SEO

Cannibalization is also referenced in the search engine optimization (SEO) industry; it is known as keyword cannibalization. Keyword cannibalization happens when multiple pages on a website specifically target the same content,[2] to the point where the search engine has a difficult time determining which page is most relevant for the search query, and thus might not necessarily promote the page one would want website visitors to see most.

Positive effects: increasing market share

A company engaging in corporate cannibalism is effectively competing against itself. There are two main reasons companies do this. Firstly, the company wants to increase its market share and is taking a gamble that introducing the new product will harm other competitors more than the company itself. Secondly, the company may believe that the new product will sell better than the first, or will sell to a different sort of buyer. For example, a company may manufacture cars, and later begin manufacturing trucks. While both products appeal to the same general market (drivers) one may fit an individual's needs better than the other. However, corporate cannibalism often has negative effects: the car manufacturer's customer base may begin buying trucks instead of cars, resulting in good truck sales, but not increasing the company's market share. There may even be a decrease. This is also called market cannibalization.

In the context of a carefully planned strategy, cannibalization can be effective, by ultimately growing the market, or better meeting consumer demands.

Cannibalization is a key consideration in product portfolio analysis. For example, when Apple introduced the iPad, it took sales away from the original Macintosh, but ultimately led to an expanded market for consumer computing hardware.

Cost assessment

To accurately determine the success of a new product it is important to understand the detriment its sales are having to older products in a company’s line up. The danger is the new products are taking from old products made by the business instead of increasing market share by taking consumers from competing products made by different businesses. A model was created in 2012 to gauge the change in sales.[3]

Sales change for focal new model (at time t) = + change in demand for other models within same brand and category + change in demand for other brands within category + change in demand for other models within same brand in other categories + change in demand for other brands in other categories + primary demand (time is in weeks)

This model needs to try and deal with three problems with accurately estimating the success of a new product. Market volatility means many new products enter and leave the market making it harder to understand what specific product is affecting the market share. Slowness of the market to react to new products that have been introduced, meaning that there has to be time scope allowing for seasonal changes and the consumers to act accordingly. Correlated error structures may permeate the brand as not just one product will be effected so it is important to understand the scope of the commodity and see total impact. The model tries to mitigate these areas of error that make older models less reliable.

There is also the danger of multiple distribution channel cannibalization which can lead to job insecurity and risk for the old channels as the new channels open. In the case of travel agencies; in the past nearly all travel groups relied on them as an intermediary for tourism, this meant face to face meetings to introduce the products or services that one group wishes to sell to the travelers. In recent years with new technology the necessity of travel agencies has been declining, with people being able to connect to the businesses they need to travel directly and cheaper than going through the more conventional means.[4] Airlines and similar tourism focused companies instead push through marketing the populace towards using their website instead of booking with a tourism agency, this is because it’s cheaper to run and can be more convenient for the consumer. So the update in technology has forced market cannibalization to cut the spending in certain business groups leading to job insecurity, decreased job satisfaction, job alienation and risk aversion.[5]

Cannibalization is a necessary evil in lot of cases. As sales plateau and decline only to stabilize at a lower amount, it is important for business to innovate and experiment in order to create something new and cutting edge to maintain market share. Strategic development is important for business and integral for moving forward. Nitin Pangarkar said it is very important for businesses to maximize competitiveness with business strategy and cannibalization is part of this.[6] Cannibalization of markets is competing with others success and self-cannibalization is competing with yourself. As Steve Jobs said when he released the iPhone: "If you don't cannibalize yourself, someone else will".[7] Even though there are dangers with cannibalization it has been very successful at pushing business innovation forward and identifying stagnant areas of a business.

Risks

The diversion of sales from one product to another or from the same product to a different product can adversely effect the overall sales of a business. Wendy Lomax theorized that using a brand name and leverage of current users of a brand to push them into using a new product can be a large risk.[8]) This is due to the damaging nature which a failed product would have on the preexisting parent product. As sales dropped from the new product after it is no longer pushed there is no guarantee that sales will stabilize to the old product that was sacrificed for the current item. One of the unavoidable risks is to the established product but for self-cannibalization and growth this is essential.

Apple cannibalized their own sales of the iPad when the iPhone 6 was released in September 2014.[9] According to a Forbes article, shipment of iPads was down 23% since the announcement of the iPhone 6. This is due to the new product (the iPhone) being large enough to have a lot of the features of the iPad without being as large making the iPad outdated and irrelevant.[10] While the iPhone shipped massive amounts of product, the iPad never recovered to its previous sales plateau. Overall, this is a positive effect as turnover of new products allows company to get old users to spend money and keeps their products current which is very important in technology related fields. This is still an example of Apple betting sales of the old product to get higher sales on a new product in this case it was a success.

See also

References

  1. ^ M.F., Goodchild (1984). "ILACS:A Location Allocation Model for Retail Site Selection". Journal of Retailing. 21 (60): 84–100. doi:10.1111/j.1538-4632.1989.tb00900.x.
  2. ^ Dimock, Matt (July 25, 2013). "The Keyword Cannibalization Survival Guide". Retrieved November 11, 2013.
  3. ^ Van Heerde, H. J., Srinivasan, S., & Dekimpe (November 2012). "Sibling Rivalry: ESTIMATING CANNIBALIZATION RATES FOR INNOVATIONS". Marketing Intelligence Review.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  4. ^ Buhalisa, D., & Lawb, R. (August 2008). "Progress in information technology and tourism management" (PDF). Tourism Management. 29 (4): 609–623. doi:10.1016/j.tourman.2008.01.005. hdl:10397/527.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  5. ^ Díaza, E., Martín-Consuegraa, D., & Estebanc, Á. (June 2015). "Perceptions of service cannibalisation: The moderating effect of the type of travel agency". Tourism Management. 48: 329–342. doi:10.1016/j.tourman.2014.12.004.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  6. ^ Pangarkar, N. Performance implications of strategic changes: An integrative framework. Business horizons. pp. 295–304.
  7. ^ Isaacson. Steve Jobs. Simon & Schuster.
  8. ^ Lomax, Wendy (1997). "Product & Brand Management". Marketing Intelligence & Planning. 6 (1): 20–28. doi:10.1108/02634509610152673.
  9. ^ Apple Press info. "Iphone announced". {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)
  10. ^ Marko. "Apples cannibalization might eat its own words". forbes. Retrieved 1 April 2016.

Read other articles:

2012 comedy play by Christopher Durang Vanya and Sonia and Masha and SpikeWritten byChristopher DurangCharacters Vanya Masha Spike Sonia Nina Cassandra Date premieredSeptember 7, 2012 (2012-09-07)Place premieredMcCarter Theatre, Princeton, New Jersey Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike is a comedy play written by Christopher Durang. The story revolves around the relationships of three middle-aged single siblings, two of whom live together, and takes place during a visit by the ...

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с фамилией Квак. Квак Чэ Ён Дата рождения 22 мая 1959(1959-05-22) (64 года) Место рождения Сувон, Республика Корея Гражданство  Республика Корея Профессия кинорежиссёр, сценарист IMDb ID 1030706 Квак Чэ Ён (кор. 곽재용?, 郭在容?) (род. 22 мая 19...

أنا بيتي البشعة   النوع رواية تلفزيونية تأليف فرناندو جايتان  بطولة آنا ماريا أوروزكو،  وخورخي إنريكي أبيلو،  ولورنا سيبيدا،  وناتاليا راميريز  البلد  كولومبيا لغة العمل الإسبانية  عدد المواسم 1   عدد الحلقات 169 القناة آر سي أن بث لأول مرة في 4 يناير 1999 ...

Artikel ini sebatang kara, artinya tidak ada artikel lain yang memiliki pranala balik ke halaman ini.Bantulah menambah pranala ke artikel ini dari artikel yang berhubungan atau coba peralatan pencari pranala.Tag ini diberikan pada Januari 2023. Ceroplesis marmorata Klasifikasi ilmiah Kerajaan: Animalia Filum: Arthropoda Kelas: Insecta Ordo: Coleoptera Famili: Cerambycidae Genus: Ceroplesis Spesies: Ceroplesis marmorata Ceroplesis marmorata adalah spesies kumbang tanduk panjang yang tergolong ...

Przykład użycia łacinki ukraińskiej Łacinka ukraińska (ukr. українська латинка, transkr. ukrajinśka łatynka; українська латиниця, transkr. ukrajinśka łatynycia) – wariant alfabetu łacińskiego przystosowany do zapisu języka ukraińskiego, opracowany w roku 1859 przez czeskiego slawistę Josefa Jirečka. Historia Użycie alfabetu łacińskiego w dobie ruskiej Teksty ruskie drukowane pojawiły się w pierwszej połowie XVI wieku[1]. Zasięg użyc...

Theodorus Marinus Roest van Limburg kan verwijzen naar: Nederlands staatsman (1806-1887): Theodorus Marinus Roest van Limburg (1806) hoofdcommissarissen van Rotterdam en later Amsterdam (1865-1935): Theodorus Marinus Roest van Limburg (1865) Bekijk alle artikelen waarvan de titel begint met Theodorus Marinus Roest van Limburg of met Theodorus Marinus Roest van Limburg in de titel. Dit is een doorverwijspagina, bedoeld om de verschillen in betekenis of gebruik van Theo...

Canadian comedian, writer, and actor Katherine RyanRyan in November 2014 at the Adelphi TheatreBornKatherine Louisa Ryan (1983-06-30) 30 June 1983 (age 40)Sarnia, Ontario, CanadaCitizenshipCanadianIrish[1]Alma materToronto Metropolitan UniversityOccupationsComedianwriteractresspresenterPartnerBobby Kootstra (c. 2019–present)Children3 Katherine Louisa Ryan (born 30 June 1983)[2] is a Canadian comedian, writer, presenter, actress and singer based in the United ...

Réserve naturelle régionale du site géologique de Vigny-LonguesseCarrière de VignyGéographiePays FranceRégion Île-de-FranceDépartement Val-d'OiseCoordonnées 49° 04′ 07″ N, 1° 55′ 22″ ESuperficie 21,87 ha[1]AdministrationType Réserve naturelle régionaleCatégorie UICN IVWDPA 555514347Création 22 octobre 2009[1]Administration Conseil général du Val-d'OiseLocalisation sur la carte de FranceLocalisation sur la carte d’Île-de-Francemodi...

本條目存在以下問題,請協助改善本條目或在討論頁針對議題發表看法。 此條目疑似为广告或包含宣传性内容。 (2021年5月10日)请协助使用中立的观点重写这篇条目。明显的广告请加入{{Delete|G11}}來提请删除。 此條目類似一篇自傳,或內容主要由條目描述的當事人或組織撰寫、編輯。 (2021年5月10日)請協助編輯以讓內容符合維基百科中立的觀點,也可到討論頁參考或發表意...

В Википедии есть статьи о других людях с такой фамилией, см. Ефремов; Ефремов, Валерий. Валерий Анатольевич ЕфремовВалерий Анатольевич Ефремов Дата рождения 1 сентября 1974(1974-09-01) (49 лет) Место рождения Ленинград, РСФСР, СССР Страна  СССР Россия Научная сфера филология, ...

Juhi ParmarJuhi Parmar di Vikas Kalantri upacara pernikahan sangeetLahir14 Desember 1980 (umur 42)Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh, IndiaPekerjaanaktrisTahun aktif1998 - sekarangSuami/istriSachin Shroff (m.2009-2017) Juhi Parmar (lahir 14 Desember 1980) adalah seorang aktris, presenter televisi, penyanyi dan penari India. Dia terkenal karena perannya sebagai Kumkum di serial televisi Kumkum Ek Pyara Sa Bandhan. Dia adalah pemenang musim kelima reality show televisi Bigg Boss yang ditayangkan ...

Federal electoral district of Germany 289 ReutlingenElectoral districtfor the BundestagReutlingen in 2009StateBaden-WürttembergPopulation287,000 (2019)Electorate199,189 (2021)Major settlementsReutlingenMetzingenPfullingenArea1,092.5 km2Current electoral districtCreated1949PartyCDUMemberMichael DonthElected2013, 2017, 2021 Reutlingen is an electoral constituency (German: Wahlkreis) represented in the Bundestag. It elects one member via first-past-the-post voting. Under the current constituenc...

Biblioteca nacional de la República Turca del Norte de ChipreUbicaciónPaís  Chipre del Norte ChipreLocalidad NicosiaDatos generalesTipo PúblicaFundación 1958[editar datos en Wikidata] La Biblioteca nacional de la República Turca del Norte de Chipre es la Biblioteca principal de la República Turca del Norte de Chipre[1]​ un estado de facto en la isla de Chipre. El edificio se localiza específicamente en Nicosia. Fue fundada el 17 de noviembre de 1958. La colec...

2016 memoir (book) by Carrie Fisher The Princess Diarist AuthorCarrie FisherAudio read byCarrie FisherCountryUnited StatesLanguageEnglishGenreHumorAutobiographyPublisherBlue Rider PressPublication dateNovember 22, 2016Pages272[1]ISBN0-399-17359-5Preceded byShockaholic  The Princess Diarist is a 2016 memoir written by Carrie Fisher, based on diaries she kept as a young woman around the time she starred in the 1977 film Star Wars. The book is the third memoir Fisher ...

United States career military officer, Union Army general (1834–1889) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: Marcus Reno – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (October 2010) (Learn how and when to remove this template message) Marcus Albert RenoMarcus A. RenoBorn(1834-11-15)November 15, 18...

Ekonomi UkrainaPusat bisnis di KievMata uang1 Hryvnia (₴) = 100 kopiykasTahun fiskalTahun kalenderOrganisasi organizationsGUAM and WTOStatistikPDB $90,138 miliar (2015, nominal)[1] $341,489 miliar (2015, KKB)[1]Pertumbuhan PDB -12,5% (2015)[2]PDB per kapita $2.100 (2015) (nominal) [1] $8.000 (2015) (KKB)[1]PDB per sektorPertanian 9,9%, Industri 29,6%, jasa 60,5% (2013 est.)[3]Inflasi (IHK)▲ 40% (2015)[4]Pendudukdi bawah garis kemiski...

Sakhnin סַחְ'נִין, סִכְנִין (nama Arab)سخنينTranskripsi bahasa Ibrani • ISO 259Saḥnin, Saknin (pengartian Israel)DistrikUtaraPemerintahan • JenisKota (sejak 1995) • Kepala DaerahMazin G'NayemLuas • Total9.816 dunams (9,816 km2 or 3,790 sq mi)Populasi (2008) • Total25.600 • Kepadatan2,6/km2 (6,8/sq mi) Sakhnin (bahasa Arab: سخنين; Ibrani: סַחְ...

Canadian biologist Anne Vallée This article includes a list of references, related reading, or external links, but its sources remain unclear because it lacks inline citations. Please help improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (February 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this message) Anne Vallée (26 July 1958, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada - 31 July 1982, Triangle Island, British Columbia, ) was one of the first biologists to observe the impact of climate change on ani...

Horizon Zero DawnGeliştiriciGuerrilla GamesYayımcıSony Interactive EntertainmentYönetmenMathijs de JongeYapımcıLambert Wolterbeek MullerTasarımcıJan-Bart van BeekProgramcıMichiel van der LeeuwSenaristlerJohn Gonzalez Ben McCawBestecilerJoris de Man The Flight Jukka RintamäkiMotorDecimaPlatformlarPlayStation 4 Microsoft WindowsTürAksiyon-rol yapma oyunuModTek oyunculu oyun  Horizon Zero Dawn Guerrilla Games tarafından geliştirilen ve Sony Interactive Entertainment tarafından...

Paghimo ni bot Lsjbot. Alang sa ubang mga dapit sa mao gihapon nga ngalan, tan-awa ang Midland Park. 41°26′41″N 96°29′17″W / 41.44472°N 96.48808°W / 41.44472; -96.48808 Midland Park Parke Nasod  Tinipong Bansa Estado Nebraska Kondado Dodge County Gitas-on 362 m (1,188 ft) Tiganos 41°26′41″N 96°29′17″W / 41.44472°N 96.48808°W / 41.44472; -96.48808 Timezone CST (UTC-6)  - summer (DST) CDT (UTC-5) GeoN...