Azzara was born in Brooklyn, the daughter of Josephine (née Bravo) and Samuel Azzara.[citation needed] She studied with Lee Strasberg and Gene Frankel and soon began appearing off-Broadway and in regional theatres.[citation needed] In the summer of 1965, she appeared as Eve in On the First Day, a one-act play written by David Graeme and directed by Charles Merlis at the 41st Street Playhouse in Manhattan.