Larry Flick for Billboard magazine gave the song a positive review by saying, "Hill made a big initial splash singing feisty uptempo numbers, but the power of her pliable, pure country voice has never been better showcased than on this heartfelt ballad about a woman who's had just about enough."[1]
Music video
A music video for the song was added to CMT's playlists for the week of May 1, 1994.[2]
Chart performance
"But I Will" debuted on the US BillboardHot Country Songs chart the week of June 4, 1994 at number 59, listed as the "Hot Shot Debut" of the week.[3] It reached a peak position of number 35 for the week of July 30, 1994, where it stayed for one week. It stayed in the charts for 12 weeks.