Its participation in that tournament continued until 1998[1] after which its place was taken by a reconstituted Combined Virgin Islands team[2] before the BVI again started participating separately for the one-day tournaments in 2003 and 2004[1] while a Combined Virgin Islands team participated in the Leeward Islands 3-day tournament.[2] In February 2002 the islands hosted their only first-class cricket match, when the Leeward Islands played the Windward Islands at the A.O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Roadtown.[3] In 2005 the BVI and USVI again ceased to participate separately in all Leeward Islands tournaments (one day and three-day tournaments) and their places were taken by the Combined Virgin Islands until 2008[2] after which they participated separately again in all Leeward Islands tournaments.[1]
As part of Allen Stanford's vision for cricket in the West Indies, the United States Virgin Islands were invited to take part in the 2006 Stanford 20/20, whose matches held official Twenty20 status.[4] Stanford gave US$100,000 for their participation.[5] They played a single match in the tournament, losing to Saint Lucia by 7 wickets in their preliminary round match.[6] Two years later, they were invited to take part in the 2008 Stanford 20/20,[4] playing a single preliminary round match against Dominica, which they lost by 66 runs.[7]
Following the reorganisation of domestic Twenty20 cricket in the West Indies in the aftermath of the fraud convictions against Allen Stanford, the United States Virgin Islands were excluded from the revamped regional tournament.[8] The team's last recorded appearance in the Leeward Islands One-Day Tournament came against Nevis in 2011.[1]