The song is written in an Italian-American dialect about the singer's eponymous brother, described in hyperbolic terms as a man of legendary strength capable of extraordinary feats. The original lyric has him blowing out a house fire, pushing the ocean away to allow him to walk to Italy, killing fifty thousand [native American] Indians, and drinking the ocean dry.
A 1955 version of the sheet music states that it is "sung by Sam Stern" and "Dedicated to my friend Sam Dody".[2]
Subsequent versions changed the references from the boxer John L. Sullivan to the "Jeffries-Johnson fight" of 1910, to American boxer Jack Dempsey, who started boxing in 1914, and even to John Conteh of Great Britain, who fought in the 1970s. Other changes have included the saving of the RMS Lusitania,[3] sunk during the first World War, and swimming from New York to Italy,[4] drinking all the water in the sea, playing every instrument in a brass band in a visit to Japan.
The song was popular with Canadian soldiers in World War II.[4]