*Club domestic league appearances and goals, correct as of 22:08, November 23, 2024 (UTC) ‡ National team caps and goals, correct as of 09:04, November 15, 2024 (UTC)
Trusty would go on to play 44 games for the Bethlehem Steel within two seasons.[8]
Philadelphia Union
On August 10, 2016, Trusty signed a homegrown player deal with the Philadelphia Union, electing not to join the Tar Heels.[9] Despite his signing, Trusty did not make his debut for the Union until March 3, 2018, in the club's season opener against the New England Revolution.[10] He finished his first season with the Union having played every minute of the season as the club finished sixth in the Eastern Conference.[10] He also scored his first professional goal on September 15 against the Montreal Impact, a 4–1 defeat.[11]
Going into the 2019 season, Trusty continued his game streak, playing in an additional seven matches before being sent off during a match against the LA Galaxy on April 13.[10][12] Following his suspension, Trusty would start 15 more matches until July 2019.
Colorado Rapids
On November 20, 2019, Trusty was traded to the Colorado Rapids in exchange for up to $750,000 in allocation money, including performance-based thresholds, as well as a percentage of a future transfer.[13] He made his debut for the club on July 17, 2020, against Sporting Kansas City in the MLS is Back Tournament, coming off the bench.[14] Following his debut season with the Rapids, Trusty signed a new contract on December 16, keeping him with the club through the 2023 season.[15]
Arsenal
On January 31, 2022, Trusty signed with Premier League club Arsenal, although he would stay on loan with the Colorado Rapids until July 17, 2022.[16][17] He played his last game for the Rapids on July 5, returned to Arsenal, and was immediately loaned to EFL Championship club Birmingham City for the 2022–23 season.[18]
Loan to Birmingham City
Trusty made his competitive debut in English football on July 30, 2022, in his new club's opening-day 0–0 draw at Luton Town.[19] He scored his first two goals in England in Birmingham's 3–0 win against Bristol City on October 8.[20] His own goal caused Birmingham's elimination from the FA Cup at the hands of Blackburn Rovers,[21] but he redeemed himself four days later with the winning goal in the seventh minute of stoppage time of the Championship match away to Swansea City.[22] As of February 10, Trusty had played every minute of every league match throughout the season.[23] He finished the season with 44 appearances in all competitions and four goals,[24] and was voted Player of the Season by Birmingham's supporters.[25]
Sheffield United
On August 3, 2023, Trusty signed for newly promoted Sheffield United.[26] He made his Premier League debut on September 16 in a 2–1 loss away to Tottenham Hotspur.[27] He scored his first goal for Sheffield United on August 13, 2024 in an EFL Cup tie against Wrexham.[28]
On December 20, 2018, Trusty, alongside then teammate Mark McKenzie, received his first call-up to the senior United States squad for their January 2019 camp.[35]
Trusty was added to the roster for the United States' January 2022 training camp in Phoenix.[36]
Trusty made his senior debut on March 24, 2023, starting the CONCACAF Nations League A group phase match against Grenada. Partnering McKenzie in central defense, Trusty played the whole game, and provided the assist for Weston McKennie's second goal of the 7–1 win.[37]
Career statistics
Club
As of match played November 23, 2024
Appearances and goals by club, season and competition