In 2000, Palmer moved to New York City where she worked in summer stock, regional and children's touring theatre and independent film before being selected for the original cast of the Off-Broadway show Pieces (of Ass). Despite her part getting cut in her first TV job, a restaurant hostess in the final season of Sex and the City, she relocated to Los Angeles in 2004 to pursue film and television work.
Once in Hollywood she studied film acting and also took improv classes at the famed Upright Citizens Brigade Theatre. In 2005 was cast in the pilot episode of Kitchen Confidential, which was based on the life of Anthony Bourdain, and could be seen canoodling with the star Bradley Cooper.[8] She performed with a comedy group and played funny roles in several web series before being considered for the lead role in the hit horror film Paranormal Activity, which she had submitted herself to, hoping to combine her improv skills with dramatic acting.
^USA Today, 9 October 2009, by: Claudia Puig, "Watch scary 'Paranormal Activity' with the lights on" USA
^Naperville Sun, 23 October 2009, by: David Sharos, "Horror Hit Boots Career of Naperville Native", Naperville, IL, USA
^Gibson, Chuck (January 15, 2010). "'Paranormal' Actress Comes Back Home for Christmas". The Loveland Herald. Loveland, Ohio: The Community Press.
^Gibson, Chuck (February 6, 2013). "Is it something in Loveland's water?". The Loveland Herald. Loveland, Ohio: The Community Press. Retrieved February 7, 2013. It was a surprise, but no accident for the 1996 Loveland High School graduate.