The authors of The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings awarded the albums a full 4 stars, and wrote: "There was a mass of good music from the Tentet, easily worthy of two volumes, and the addition of trombone... and tuba restores something of an earlier sound to Brötzmann's ensemble-work."[8]
Critic Tom Hull assigned both volumes grades of "B+"[9] and awarded them "honorable mentions" in his October 16, 2007, Village Voice column, commenting "Big birds have deep, rumbling hearts... which swell over time, pumping longer and louder."[10]
Mark Corroto of All About Jazz commented: "Brötzmann's recent compositions allow for quiet resolutions and improvised interludes that pair players up... But always there is the power of the bigger group lurking. It bubbles up repeatedly, offering the crowd what they've come for. But tucked inside the thunder are composed lines that sway and sizzle."[11]
Track listings
Volume 1
"American Landscapes 1" – 43:39
Volume 2
"American Landscapes 2" – 52:48
Personnel
Peter Brötzmann – tenor saxophone, alto saxophone, clarinet, tárogató