1998–1999 Ecuador economic crisis

The 1998–99 Ecuador economic crisis was a period of economic instability that resulted from a combined inflationary-currency crisis, financial crisis, fiscal crisis, and sovereign debt crisis.[1] Severe inflation and devaluation of the sucre led to President Jamil Mahuad announcing on January 9, 2000 that the U.S. dollar would be adopted as the national currency. Poor economic conditions and subsequent protests against the government resulted in the 2000 Ecuadoran coup d’état in which Jamil Mahuad was forced to resign and was replaced by his Vice President, Gustavo Noboa.

Background

Throughout the 20th century, Ecuador was one of the poorer countries in Latin America, and had high rates of poverty and income inequality compared to other countries in the region. By the late 1990s around 45% of the population lived below the national poverty line, making them especially vulnerable.[1] The discovery of oil in the 1960s led to rapid economic growth, but created an economy that was dependent on exports of oil and agricultural products such as bananas, coffee, and shrimp. Lower oil prices resulted in economic stagnation throughout the 1980s and into the 1990s, as oil exports alone accounted for half of the country's total exports and about a third of all government revenue in the late 1990s.[1][2] Ecuador's population and economy can be geographically divided into three general regions: the Pacific coastal region in the west, the central Andean highlands, and the eastern Amazonian regions. 95% of the population lives on the coast or the central highlands, and accounts for the majority of Ecuador's economic activity. The Amazonian regions are mostly populated by indigenous people who are generally poorer, despite the fact that the Amazon contains Ecuador's significant oil reserves. Across all three regions, poverty is much worse in rural areas than in urban areas. Ecuador's social and economic inequalities have contributed to internal tensions and political divides on a national level, which became evident during the government's response to the financial crisis.[3][2]

Causes

In 2010, author and professor Alberto Valencia Granada published a book called When Success is a Crime: Filanbanco: A Case of Violation of Human Rights in Ecuador. His book summarizes the causes of the financial crisis:

In the late 1990s, Ecuador (and the entire region) experienced capital flight following the East Asian and Russian crises. Ecuador then experienced a political-economic crisis that was aggravated by many factors: military confrontation with Peru, lack of sufficient hydroelectric energy production (due to low water levels), and difficulties in the agricultural sector because of the El Niño weather phenomenon. These factors together deepened the political crisis in the country — a time period that saw four presidents within eight years. The biggest victims of the economic crisis were the agricultural export industry located along the coasts, which were Filanbanco’s principal credit recipients. Lack of payments from these customers, combined with restrictions on opening new lines of international credit, squeezed the bank. Thus, the bank turned to other companies within the Isaias Group for cash along with liquidity loans from the Central Bank.[4][5]

Structural weaknesses in Ecuador

Economic conditions in Ecuador allowed the development of a weak financial system which was more vulnerable to disruptions. The financial sector was also affected by the regional fragmentation between policy makers in the capital, Quito, and banks based in the port city of Guayaquil, the most populous city and economic centre of the country in 1999. Financial liberalization policies had been adopted in the early 1990s by conservative president Sixto Durán-Ballén and his vice president Alberto Dahik (widely considered the economic tsar of the government and mastermind of neoliberal policies),[6] allowing easier access to international markets and investors, but they also created a largely deregulated domestic financial sector.[1][2][3] Many Ecuadoran banks were well connected to prominent business groups and politicians, and financial supervision and regulation was not strongly enforced. As a result, Ecuadoran banks experienced a credit boom in the 1990s, providing high-risk loans to well-connected customers, assuming that the government and Central Bank would bail them out if needed.[1][7] Lack of oversight also allowed many banks to engage in lucrative but risky offshore banking in U.S. dollar denominations, creating an informal dollarization of the financial sector, and a vulnerability to fluctuations in the exchange rate.[3]

Shocks and vulnerability

Ecuador's public finances in the 1990s were heavily dependent on oil revenue, and public spending was high. In the short term, the financial crisis was triggered by a series of external shocks. A severe El Niño in 1997–1998 caused heavy rains and flooding that caused widespread crop failures and damaged infrastructure costing approximately 13% of its GDP. These shocks occurred soon after several financial crises in Asia (1997), Russia (1998), and Brazil (1998), which were damaging to the world economy. In this context, global financial institutions were more reluctant to offer credit lines to Ecuador and other developing countries.[1][3] Oil prices plunged in 1998, partly in response to global economic slowdown following the Asian financial crisis, which significantly reduced the government's revenues. These shocks created a situation where the public deficit grew uncontrollably, as the government had to recover from El Niño damage, but had restricted access to oil revenues and international financing. For example, the public sector deficit increased from 2.6% of GDP in 1997 to 6.2% in 1998.[8]

Ecuador was also undergoing a period of political vulnerability in the 1990s. The fragmentation and divided politics of the country resulted in a relatively weak state throughout the 1990s, which never gained widespread support. Populist president Abdalá Bucaram, known as "El Loco", was declared mentally unfit by Congress and fled after nation-wide protests in 1997, and an interim government under Fabián Alarcón was in power until Jamil Mahuad was elected in 1998, just as the banking crisis was developing.[8][9]

Crisis and government response

The economic crisis began in the context of increasing public debt and poor economic performance on a national level. In the private financial sector, banks had given out excessively risky loans, and were struggling to maintain liquidity. The banking crisis started in April 1998 with the failure of a small bank, but the ensuing atmosphere of uncertainty caused excessive withdrawals and triggered more bank failures throughout 1998. By August, important bank failures had reached the point where the government could no longer intervene by bailing out and supporting struggling banks.[3] By December, the "AGD law" (Agencia de Garantía de Depósitos) set up deposit insurance, in an attempt to discourage further withdrawals.[2] Another law starting in January 1999 established a 1% tax on any financial transactions, which would discourage withdrawals and raise revenue for the struggling government.[3] However, this tax proved devastating for both the financial system and ordinary people as it discouraged all financial activity and did not prevent deposit withdrawals. Other proposed government policies included increases in general sales taxes and gasoline taxes.[10]

By early 1999, major banks were failing and being taken over and closed by the AGD, while still providing a deposit guarantee. Increasing consumer prices and the depreciation of the Sucre raised fears of hyperinflation, and in March 1999 the government declared a national bank holiday, which ended up lasting a full week from March 8–12.[11] At the end of the holiday, the government announced a partial deposit freeze in which dollar-denominated bank deposits were frozen for between six months to a year.[12][13] This did temporarily slow inflation, but it caused the collapse of trust in the banking system and poor economic conditions.[11][13] Throughout 1999, the government did gradually unfreeze deposits, but this was followed by widespread withdrawals and more bank failure, due to a lack of confidence in the banks.[13] By September, the government itself had defaulted on external debts as it had spent significant resources supporting the central bank and its deposit guarantees.[2][3]

Economic effects

Dollarization

Despite the government's efforts to curb inflation, the Sucre depreciated rapidly at the end of 1999, resulting in widespread informal use of U.S. dollars in the financial system. As a last resort to prevent hyperinflation, the government formally adopted the U.S. dollar in January 2000. The stability of the new currency was a necessary first step towards economic recovery, but the exchange rate was fixed at 25,000:1, which resulted in great losses of wealth.[2]

Poverty and living conditions

The severe effects of the financial crisis were especially visible in Ecuador because of the preexisting problems of poverty and national inequality. The general economic uncertainty resulted in loss of jobs and wealth, which had the most significant effect on people who were already vulnerable. The government was financially limited due to its debt defaults, and had to focus on macroeconomic solutions rather than the social problems that developed during the financial crisis. Measures of poverty, including extreme poverty and the poverty gap, all increased during the crisis and peaked in 1999. Rural areas were especially affected, and metrics such as worse child nutrition, reduced educational spending, and poor health outcomes all showed that the financial crisis had severe effects. An estimated 200,000 Ecuadorans also left the country between 1998 and 2000, representing 2% of the labor force of the country.[3]

Political effects

President Jamil Mahuad suffered declining popularity ratings throughout the financial crisis, decreasing from 60% in 1998 to 6% in early 2000. The dollarization policy proved to be particularly unpopular even if it was implemented successfully. Protests led by a coalition of indigenous peoples (CONAIE) and supported by the military occupied congress and forced President Mahuad to resign.[14]

Social effects

Migration to the United States

The Ecuadoran financial crisis caused massive migrations, primarily to the United States and Spain. Between the years 1999 and 2000, approximately 400,000 Ecuadorans migrated to the United States.[15] This was not the first wave of Ecuadoran migration to the U.S., and so this wave of migrants joined roughly half a million other Ecuadorans who had already paved the way for migration. Most Ecuadorans who migrated to the U.S. as a result of the Ecuadoran financial crisis were from the regions of Azuay and Cañar.[15] The largest community of Ecuadorans in the U.S. resides in the New York metropolitan area.[15] Half of the Ecuadoran diaspora is within the United States.[15]

Ecuadoran migration to the US has become increasingly transnational in nature. This is due in part to remittances sent back to communities in Ecuador by migrant communities in the US. The sending of these remittances facilitates a continuous connection between migrants and those at home, which in turn facilitates further migration.[16] Remittances to Ecuador were at around $643 million in 1997, and increased $1.41 billion in 2001 which highlights the sudden impact emigration had on Ecuador.[16]

Migration to Spain

Many Ecuadorians migrated to Spain in search of financial opportunity, as Spain's economy had been flourishing. Around 7,000 Ecuadorians arrived to Spain each month in 2000. This early wave left Ecuador during the hardest part of the economic crisis and was composed of young people eager to work. By 2005, the Ecuadorian community in Spain was around 500,000 people. During the period until 2004, the migrants were mainly composed family members joining those who had first migrated.[17] The Ecuadorian diaspora in Spain differs from the U.S. one in that Ecuadorians experienced greater economic prosperity in Spain. They sent up to 46% of their salary, 16% invested in improving living conditions for their families back in Ecuador.[18] A lot of which were young kids reuniting with their parents, such kids grew up in Spain, attended school, and are now making up the second generation of Ecuadorians in Spain.

References

  1. ^ a b c d e f Montiel, Peter J. (2014). "Ecuador 1999: triple crisis and dollarization". Ten Crises. London: Routledge.
  2. ^ a b c d e f Jácome, Luis Ignacio; LJá[email protected] (2004). "The Late 1990s Financial Crisis in Ecuador: Institutional Weaknesses, Fiscal Rigidities, and Financial Dollarization At Work". IMF Working Papers. 04 (12): 1. doi:10.5089/9781451842937.001. S2CID 167869452.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h Beckerman, Paul; Solimano, Andrés (2002). Crisis and Dollarization in Ecuador: Stability, Growth, and Social Equity. Washington, D.C.: World Bank.
  4. ^ Amelio, Juan (2019-08-15). "The Curious Case of Filanbanco and the Isaias Brothers". Medium. Retrieved 2019-08-28.
  5. ^ Granada, Alberto Valencia (6 June 2015). When Success is a Crime: Violation of Human Rights to Isaias Family in Ecuador. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. ISBN 978-1514220740.
  6. ^ Conaghan, Catherine M.; Malloy, James (1995-01-15). Unsettling Statecraft: Democracy and Neoliberalism in the Central Andes. University of Pittsburgh Pre. p. 229. ISBN 978-0-8229-7465-9.
  7. ^ Martinez, Gabriel X. (2006-07-01). "The political economy of the Ecuadorian financial crisis". Cambridge Journal of Economics. 30 (4): 567–585. doi:10.1093/cje/bei097. ISSN 0309-166X.
  8. ^ a b "Ecuador and the IMF -- Address by Stanley Fischer". www.imf.org. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
  9. ^ "Austerity and Disorder In the Andes". NACLA. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
  10. ^ "Washingtonpost.com: Ecuador Faces Harsh Economic Measures". www.washingtonpost.com. Retrieved 2017-04-23.
  11. ^ a b McDermott, Jeremy (March 11, 1999). "Strike-hit Ecuador declares 60-day state of emergency". The Daily Telegraph (London, England). p. 25.
  12. ^ "Ecuador endures new turmoil as unrest over austerity intensifies". The Miami Herald. p. 1A, 7A.
  13. ^ a b c "Ecuador eases up on frozen accounts". Bloomberg News. The Miami Herald. April 6, 1999. p. 2C.
  14. ^ "BBC News | AMERICAS | Coup declared in Ecuador". news.bbc.co.uk. Retrieved 2017-04-24.
  15. ^ a b c d Kyle, David (June 2011). "Migration Industries: A Comparison of the Ecuador-US and Ecuador-Spain Cases". Cadmus.
  16. ^ a b Jokisch, Brad; Pribilsky, Jason (2002-12-15). "The Panic to Leave: Economic Crisis and the 'New Emigration' from Ecuador". The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering. 40 (4): 75–102. doi:10.1111/1468-2435.00206.
  17. ^ "628.308 ecuatorianos emigraron desde el 2000 - ENE. 21, 2005 - Migración - Historicos - EL UNIVERSO". www.eluniverso.com. 21 January 2005. Retrieved 2019-05-09.
  18. ^ FEPP, ALER (2001). El proceso migratorio de ecuatorianos a españa.

Read other articles:

Atom of helium This article is about the physics of atomic helium. For other properties of helium, see Helium. Helium atom Helium-4 Names Systematic IUPAC name Helium[1] Identifiers CAS Number 7440-59-7 Y 3D model (JSmol) Interactive image ChEBI CHEBI:33681 Y ChemSpider 22423 Y EC Number 231-168-5 Gmelin Reference 16294 KEGG D04420 N MeSH Helium PubChem CID 23987 RTECS number MH6520000 UNII 206GF3GB41 Y UN number 1046 InChI InChI=1S/He YKey: SWQJXJOG...

 

Bengbu 蚌埠市PangpuPrefekturJulukan: Kota Mutiara (珠城)Lokasi kota Bengbu, AnhuiKoordinat: 32°55′N 117°23′E / 32.917°N 117.383°E / 32.917; 117.383Koordinat: 32°55′N 117°23′E / 32.917°N 117.383°E / 32.917; 117.383NegaraTiongkokProvinsiAnhuiDivisi County7Divisi Township74Municipal seatDistrik LongzihuPemerintahan • Wali kotaZhou Chunyu (周春雨) • secretary of municipal Party committeeChen Qitao...

 

BacemTahu yang dibacemTempat asalIndonesiaDaerahJawa Tengah, DI Yogyakarta, Jawa BaratSunting kotak info • L • BBantuan penggunaan templat ini Bacem atau baceman (Jawa: ꦧꦕꦼꦩ꧀, translit. Bacěm) merupakan sajian panganan dari daerah Mataraman seperti kota Semarang, Surakarta, Magelang, dan wilayah eks Karesidenan Banyumas di Jawa Tengah; Tasikmalaya di Jawa Barat dan DI Yogyakarta. Orang Yogyakarta menyukai bacem yang bercitarasa manis, yaitu dengan bumbu khas ...

City in Texas, United States This article is about the city in Texas. For the metropolitan area, see Greater San Antonio. For other uses, see San Antonio (disambiguation). City in Texas, United StatesSan AntonioCityDowntown San AntonioAlamo MissionRiver WalkEmily Morgan HotelTower of the AmericasFrost Bank CenterNorth Star MallSan Antonio Botanical Garden FlagSealCoat of armsNickname(s): San Antone[1][2][3][4] Alamo City, Military City USA, River City, The...

 

County in Georgia, United States County in GeorgiaPolk CountyCountyPolk County Courthouse in CedartownLocation within the U.S. state of GeorgiaGeorgia's location within the U.S.Coordinates: 34°00′N 85°11′W / 34°N 85.18°W / 34; -85.18Country United StatesState GeorgiaFoundedDecember 20, 1851; 173 years ago (1851)Named forJames K. PolkSeatCedartownLargest cityCedartownArea • Total312 sq mi (810 km2) •&...

 

Yigael YadinNama asliיגאל סוקניקLahir(1917-03-20)20 Maret 1917Yerusalem, Kekaisaran UtsmaniyahMeninggal28 Juni 1984(1984-06-28) (umur 67)Yerusalem, IsraelPengabdian Haganah Israel Defense Forces Lama dinas1932–52Pangkat Letnan jenderal Chief of Staff Perang/pertempuran Pemberontakan Arab di Palestina 1936–1939 Perang Dunia II Perang Palestina 1948 Pekerjaan lainArkeolog Yigael Yadin (Ibrani: יִגָּאֵל יָדִין, terlahir Yigael Sukenik (Ibrani: יג�...

Untuk makanan lain dengan nama yang sama, lihat kelepon. Bola wijen biasa (kuning) dan bola wijen hitam Bola wijen kacang hijau Onde-onde[1] atau bola wijen (Hanzi: 煎堆; Pinyin: jiānduī; Yale (Bahasa Kanton): jīndēui) adalah sejenis kue jajanan pasar yang terkenal di Indonesia. Bola wijen mudah ditemukan di pasar tradisional maupun dijual di pedagang kaki lima. Bola wijen juga terkenal khususnya di daerah pecinan baik di Indonesia maupun luar negeri. Bola wijen terb...

 

Classic rock radio station in New York City This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these template messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed.Find sources: WAXQ – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (August 2021...

 

Palestinian news agency in Gaza Gaza Now News NetworkArabic: غزة الآنFormation2006FounderMustafa Ayyash[1]TypeNews agencyHeadquartersGaza City, Gaza, PalestineArea served WorldwideProductsWire service, News, Photos, VideoOfficial language Arabic, EnglishWebsitegazaalan.net Gaza Now News Network is a Hamas-aligned[2][3][4][5] Palestinian news agency based in Gaza. Its Telegram channel, Facebook page, and television station are among the most popu...

English idiomatic expression Sea change or sea-change is an English idiomatic expression that denotes a substantial change in perspective, especially one that affects a group or society at large, on a particular issue. It is similar in usage and meaning to a paradigm shift, and may be viewed as a change to a society or community's zeitgeist, with regard to a specific issue. The phrase evolved from an older and more literal usage when the term referred to an actual change wrought by the sea,&#...

 

Irish family of chieftains and nobles (known as Mac Wiliam Uachtar) in Connacht, Ireland For the unincorporated community in Indiana, see Clanricarde, Indiana. Upper Mac WilliamMac William Uachtar1333–1544Common languagesIrishReligion Roman CatholicismGovernmentTanistryChief • 1333-1353 Ulick Burke of Annaghkeen• 1538-1544 Ulick na gCeann Burke• 1544-1551 Sir Uilleag Burke (disputed) History • Established 1333• Disestablished 1544 Preceded b...

 

Hereditary patriotic society A page of Dinner, Huguenot Society of America, Delmonico's, New York, NY The Huguenot Society of America is a hereditary patriotic society, organized in New York City on April 12, 1883, and incorporated on June 12, 1885. About Emblem of The Huguenot Society of America The Huguenot Society of America is a New York City–based genealogical organization. On April 12, 1883, the Society was inaugurated by a group of descendants of Huguenots who had fled persecution in...

Vice President of the Philippines from 2016 to 2022 In this Philippine name for married women, the birth middle name or maternal family name is Santo Tomas, the birth surname or paternal family name is Gerona, and the marital name is Robredo. Her ExcellencyLeni RobredoOfficial portrait, 201614th Vice President of the PhilippinesIn officeJune 30, 2016 – June 30, 2022PresidentRodrigo DutertePreceded byJejomar BinaySucceeded bySara DuterteCo-Chairperson of the Inter-Agency Co...

 

Untuk kegunaan lain, lihat Ungu (disambiguasi). Ungu      Koordinat warnaTriplet hex#8000FFsRGBB    (r, g, b)(128, 0, 255)CMYKH   (c, m, y, k)(50, 100, 0, 0)HSV       (h, s, v)(270°, 100%, 100%)SumberPerBang.dkB: Dinormalkan ke [0–255] (bita)H: Dinormalkan ke [0–100] (ratusan) Ungu atau Violet adalah warna sebuah cahaya pada spektrum yang terlihat, antara biru dan ultraviolet yang tidak dapat dilihat. warna ungu adalah salah satu dari tuju...

 

2005 live album by Grateful DeadGrateful Dead Download Series Volume 5Live album by Grateful DeadReleasedSeptember 6, 2005RecordedMarch 27, 1988Length142:31LabelGrateful Dead ProductionsGrateful Dead chronology Grateful Dead Download Series Volume 4(2005) Grateful Dead Download Series Volume 5(2005) Grateful Dead Download Series Volume 6(2005) Download Series Volume 5 is a live album by the rock band the Grateful Dead. It includes the complete concert recorded on March 27, 1988, at th...

宿北战役第二次国共内战的一部分宿遷縣山东野战军日期1946年底地点江苏省宿迁县结果 中国人民解放军胜利,歼灭国军整編第69师参战方 山东野战军华中野战军 国民革命军整编第69师国民革命军整编第11师指挥官与领导者 粟裕 戴之奇×饒少偉胡璉兵力 24个团 6个半旅,14个团伤亡与损失 -8,000 2.1万 宿北战役是指1946年12月,山东野战军和华中野战军指挥机构合并后发动的第一...

 

Fiksi interaktif atau cerkan interaktif (bahasa Inggris: Interactive fiction, sering disingkat IF) adalah lingkungan yang disimulasikan perangkat lunak tempat pemain menggunakan perintah teks untuk mengontrol karakter dan memengaruhi lingkungan. Karya dalam bentuk ini dapat dipahami sebagai narasi sastra, baik dalam bentuk narasi interaktif. Karya-karya ini juga dapat dipahami sebagai bentuk permainan video,[1] baik dalam bentuk permainan petualangan atau permainan role-playing. D...

 

Comune in Piedmont, ItalySan Maurizio d'OpaglioComuneComune di San Maurizio d'OpaglioSan Maurizio d'OpaglioLocation of San Maurizio d'Opaglio San Maurizio d'OpaglioLocation of San Maurizio d'Opaglio in ItalyShow map of ItalySan Maurizio d'OpaglioSan Maurizio d'Opaglio (Piedmont)Show map of PiedmontCoordinates: 45°46′N 8°23′E / 45.767°N 8.383°E / 45.767; 8.383CountryItalyRegionPiedmontProvinceNovara (NO)FrazioniSazza, Pascolo, Lagna, Alpiolo, Opagliolo, Bacchior...

Calendar year Millennium: 2nd millennium Centuries: 17th century 18th century 19th century Decades: 1700s 1710s 1720s 1730s 1740s Years: 1724 1725 1726 1727 1728 1729 1730 February 11: The Siege of Gibraltar begins. 1727 by topic Arts and science Archaeology Architecture Art Literature Poetry Music Science Countries Canada Denmark France Great Britain Ireland Norway Russia Scotland Spain Sweden Lists of leaders State leaders Colonial governors Religious leaders Birth and ...

 

Questa voce o sezione sull'argomento Puglia è priva o carente di note e riferimenti bibliografici puntuali. Sebbene vi siano una bibliografia e/o dei collegamenti esterni, manca la contestualizzazione delle fonti con note a piè di pagina o altri riferimenti precisi che indichino puntualmente la provenienza delle informazioni. Puoi migliorare questa voce citando le fonti più precisamente. Segui i suggerimenti del progetto di riferimento. Cutrofianocomune Cutrofiano – VedutaAbside de...